Alternatives to a push-pull pot on a Strat

Wiring series #2.

The conical control knobs on a Stratocaster are less than ideal for push-pull switches - think mid-gig sweaty hands. Here are some alternatives that give you the same switching options without the slippery pull-up struggle.

Push-push pot

How it works: Push once to engage, push again to disengage.

Pros: You can tell on/off by how the knob sits relative to the guitar face.

Cons: Needs inward travel, so the knob can’t sit as flush to the body as a standard pot.

Fender S1-style pot

How it works: A push-push action with the button built into the top of the volume knob.

Pros: Very stealthy, also great for more complex switching because it has extra connections.

Cons: Made only by Fender, so it's pricier; uses special knobs that only come with a “VOLUME” engraving.

Separate toggle switch

How it works: Add a dedicated toggle (like the mod on David Gilmour’s Black Strat).

Pros: Can be very unobtrusive if you use a recessed switch like David’s guitar.

Cons: Requires drilling the pickguard, which some players don’t want to do.

Replace the second tone pot with a rotary switch

How it works: Swap the tone pot for a rotary switch.

Pros: Keeps controls looking standard. Also can have extra positions for more options.

Cons: A bit clunky and less elegant than other options.

Pick the one that fits your style and willingness to modify the guitar — stealthy and clean (S1), simple and no-drill (push-push), vintage-mod vibe (toggle), or functional-but-awkward (rotary).

Diagrams are abundant online, but if you’d rather not tackle soldering yourself, contact Rabbit Guitars - wiring mods are one of our specialties.

© Copyright 2025 Rabbit Guitars